Conservation Values at Gospel Rock
Questions from Us
On June 18, 2010, SCCA Executive Director Dan Bouman emailed a list of questions to the Conservation Data Center. His email is here.
From: Daniel Bouman
To: Carmen Cadrin
Just further to our conversation today, I'd like to make a request for information.
Could you comment, based on CDC information inventory,
- on the conservation status and value of land with in the Coastal Western Hemlock extra-dry maritime subzone?
- on the significance or priority for conservation of the 02/03 plant association?
The parcel of land we are concerned with is waterfront in the Gospel Rock area of the Town of Gibsons. It has both young and mature trees between the ages 60 and 160 years, typically averaging about 80-100 years. The area has a road through it and has alien species, particularly near the road way.
- does the presence of alien species and the degrading influence of a road make land unsuitable for conservation?
- do these circumstances preclude the development of "old growth" over time?
- are there recognized workable approaches to mitigating problems stemming from alien species and road influences?
Also, natural opening occur within both the CWHxm 02 and 03 associations in general and also within the Gospel Rock area. If land of this classification were to be placed under a covenant, would the covenant-holder need to undertake any activity, such as cutting trees down, in order to protect the ecological value of these natural openings?
And finally, would it be unusual or inappropriate, in your experience, for a municipality to protect land through a zoning by-law strictly for its environmental/ecological value?
Thank you very much for your consideration.
Executive Director, Sunshine Coast Conservation Association
Answers from BC's Conservation Data Centre
Dear Mr. Bouman
Thank you for contacting the Conservation Data Centre, Ecology program. It is always encouraging to hear from those who are taking personal responsibility for stewardship of ecological and biological diversity in British Columbia. Collaborative efforts of individuals, organizations and governing bodies can collectively make the difference that is needed.
In response to your questions, I am including here summaries of the CDC methodologies related to two Ecological Communities you have asked about: Douglas-fir - lodgepole pine / grey rock-moss (Pseudotsuga menziesii – Pinus contorta / Racomitrium canescens), Woodland Sensitive Ecosystem; and Douglas-fir - western hemlock / salal Dry Maritime (Pseudotsuga menziesii – Tsuga heterophylla / Gaultheria shallon Dry Maritime), Mature Forest Sensitive Ecosystem.
These two ecosystems are listed by the CDC, as Imperilled and Imperilled to Vulnerable, respectively, using the NatureServe methodology for conservation status assessments available at our website. The criteria applied to status assessments include information on distribution, occurrence, ecological integrity, trends, threats, vulnerability and environmental limitations.
The occurrence of these two ecosystems within the Coastal Western Hemlock, very dry maritime, occurs on the Sunshine Coast, the Lower Mainland, and east Vancouver Island. In the Lower Mainland, the forest landscape has been extensively converted to other uses, including urban/rural residential, industrial, agricultural, transportation corridors. Ecosystems on east Vancouver Island are somewhat less extensively converted. The Sunshine Coast has the most extensive remaining area, and as such, agencies and individuals in this area carry a significant proportion of the remaining stewardship options and responsibilities for the conservation of these ecosystems.
The Ministry of Environment Ecosystems Branch has developed a Conservation Framework to assist in prioritizing species and ecosystems most in need of conservation action, and recommendations for the most needed conservation actions. Both of these ecosystems are identified as Priority 2 (out of 6 classes) with recommended actions including Private Land Stewardship, Ecosystem Protection, Planning, Inventory and Monitoring.
The Sensitive Ecosystems Inventory of the Sunshine Coast and Adjacent Islands was undertaken by Environment Canada (Canadian Wildlife Service) and Ministry of Environment (Resource Inventory Branch) in 1999-2005, and supported by stakeholders including Sunshine Coast, Powell River and Strathcona Regional Districts, local First Nations and others. The criteria for mapping Sensitive Ecosystems included ecological sensitivity (limiting site requirements and site requirements that are most vulnerable to disturbance, such as shallow soils, water table and water flow requirements), and the ecological integrity of forested ecosystems. The above ecosystems met the criteria for sensitive ecosystems and occur in your area of interest, on mapsheet 92G.033, polygons 6 and 7.
With respect to your questions on invasive species, their presence does not preclude the conservation of ecosystems. If this were the case, conservation efforts by all levels of government, and other organizations, would not be occurring in the Okanagan Basin or the Georgia Basin. Stewardship and restoration efforts are high priorities for those interested in conserving the rich ecological and biological diversity typical of these regions.
There are many organizations who are effectively managing for invasive species, Scotch broom is one of them. Please go to the GOERT website for information on managing this species . Travel corridors are one of the common ways in which invasive species are introduced to an area as vehicular traffic can carry the seeds and the road allowance itself exposes mineral soil in which invasive species most easily germinate and establish.
Planting alternative non-invasive or native species along roadsides, and having active volunteers/agencies to patrol the roadside and manage the invasive species are two ways of mitigating the effects of transportation corridors.
Old growth is a term which primarily describes the structure of a forest. The presence of invasive species does not preclude the development of old growth coniferous forest. The old age of conifer species, the occurrence of standing and down dead wood, a diversity of layers in the vegetation, from ground lichens and mosses, low herbs and grasses, low and tall shrub layers, and multiple ages of tree species, are the major characteristics of old forests. Mature forest will have some, but not all, or only minor amounts of these characteristics.
With respect to zoning by-laws and covenants), I would refer you to the following references: the Green Bylaws Toolkit and the Land Trust Alliance website respectively. It is my understanding that both of these processes include consultation among stakeholders, local governments and residents, with management requirements decisions based on individual circumstances.
In my experience, where covenants are established for the protection of natural areas, the removal of natural vegetation is not recommended, and would only be undertaken under specialized conditions. Where this has occurred has been primarily in the grasslands and Ponderosa pine forest of BC’s southern interior, where fire suppression has altered the natural ecosystems (e.g. Rocky Mountain Trench Ecosystem Restoration Program, prescribed fire for grassland ecosystems).
I know that some local governments have tree cutting by-laws and Development Permit Areas that identify Sensitive Ecosystem polygons in their area (e.g. Saanich municipality has a DPA category
“protection of the natural environment, its eco-systems, and biological diversity".
Please don’t hesitate to contact me again for clarification or sources.
Carmen Cadrin, R.P.Bio, P.Ag.
CDC Program Ecologist
cc: Jan Kirkby, Canadian Wildlife Service